America’s Hard Reset: The Trump Doctrine and India’s Balancing Act

Can India safeguard its autonomy amid US-led geopolitical realignments?

Must Read

Lt Col Manoj K Channan
Lt Col Manoj K Channan
Lt Col Manoj K Channan (Retd) served in the Indian Army, Armoured Corps, 65 Armoured Regiment, 27 August 83- 07 April 2007. Operational experience in the Indian Army includes Sri Lanka – OP PAWAN, Nagaland and Manipur – OP HIFAZAT, and Bhalra - Bhaderwah, District Doda Jammu and Kashmir, including setting up of a counter-insurgency school – OP RAKSHAK. He regularly contributes to Defence and Security issues in the Financial Express online, Defence and Strategy, Fauji India Magazine and Salute Magazine. *Views are personal.

Donald J. Trump’s return to the White House as the 47th President of the United States marks a significant moment in global politics. On 20 January 2025, his inaugural address outlined a vision of American resurgence, focusing on economic protectionism, energy independence, military assertiveness, and a redefined immigration policy. Trump’s rhetoric and proposed policies are poised to have profound implications for international relations, trade, energy dynamics, and geopolitical alignments, particularly for India.

As India navigates its own economic and strategic priorities in an increasingly polarized world, it is crucial to understand the potential ramifications of Trump’s second presidency. His stance on trade, energy, foreign policy, and immigration will influence India’s economic trajectory, diplomatic engagements, and strategic partnerships. This article examines the key takeaways from Trump’s address and their potential impact on India and the broader global order.

US Immigration Policy: Its Impact on India

One of India’s most immediate concerns is Trump’s aggressive stance on immigration. His declaration of a national emergency at the southern border and commitment to deport “millions of criminal aliens” signals a tightening of immigration policies. While this measure primarily targets illegal immigrants, it could lead to a more restrictive overall immigration framework, affecting Indian professionals and students aspiring to work or study in the US.

With its large diaspora in the US, particularly in the tech and healthcare sectors, India must closely monitor potential visa policy changes. Any alterations to H-1B and student visa programs could significantly affect India’s skilled workforce and the remittances they send back home. Moreover, stricter immigration controls could create talent shortages in American industries that rely heavily on Indian professionals.

Energy Policy Shift: End of Green New Deal and Focus on Fossil Fuels

Trump’s vow to dismantle the Green New Deal and reinvest in fossil fuels could lead to a resurgence of the US coal, oil, and gas industries. While this may reduce American dependency on foreign energy sources, it also significantly impacts global climate policies and energy markets.

This shift could present challenges and opportunities for India, which has been making substantial investments in renewable energy. The phasing out of US support for green energy initiatives might slow down global renewable energy innovation and funding. However, India’s solar and wind energy sectors could attract greater global interest as alternative investment destinations.

Furthermore, lower global oil prices due to increased American drilling could benefit India, a major oil importer. Yet, this could also weaken India’s renewable energy commitments under international climate agreements, as cheaper fossil fuels might tempt policymakers to slow the transition to clean energy.

Trade Protectionism and the Establishment of the External Revenue Service

 One of the most consequential announcements in Trump’s speech was the establishment of the “External Revenue Service” to impose tariffs and taxes on imports. This move aims to boost American manufacturing but could have severe consequences for global trade, including India’s exports.

The US is one of India’s largest trading partners, with significant pharmaceuticals, textiles, and IT services exports. Increased tariffs could hurt Indian businesses that are reliant on the American market. India may need to renegotiate trade agreements or explore alternative markets to mitigate potential losses. Additionally, the possibility of reciprocal trade restrictions could escalate tensions, affecting global supply chains.

India must also assess whether it needs a similar mechanism to protect its industries. With domestic manufacturing initiatives such as “Make in India,” there may be merit in evaluating selective trade barriers to support homegrown businesses against aggressive foreign competition.

Geopolitical Realignment: India’s Strategic Importance

Trump’s assertion that “America was humbled to lead” suggests a renewed emphasis on US dominance in global affairs. However, this stance overlooks the rising influence of China and other emerging powers.

India’s External Affairs Minister, S. Jaishankar, was the only prominent foreign dignitary seated opposite the inaugural podium. This signals India’s growing strategic importance to the US. As tensions with China continue to shape global politics, the US may strengthen ties with India to counterbalance Beijing’s influence.

This could translate into enhanced defense cooperation, intelligence sharing, and strategic dialogues between the two nations. However, India must carefully navigate its partnerships to maintain its position as an independent global player, balancing relationships with the US and China.

Space Exploration and Military Expansion

Trump’s commitment to expanding American territory and planting the US flag on Mars underscores a renewed emphasis on space exploration. While this ambition is mainly symbolic, it highlights the potential for increased investments in space technology.

Through its space agency, ISRO, India has made significant strides in satellite technology and interplanetary missions. A more space-focused US administration could foster greater collaboration between NASA and ISRO, paving the way for joint missions and technology-sharing agreements.

Additionally, Trump’s broader vision of expanding US influence militarily raises concerns about global security dynamics. If the US pursues a more aggressive military stance, particularly in Asia, India may find itself in a complex geopolitical environment requiring delicate diplomatic maneuvering.

Economic Nationalism and the Panama Canal Controversy

Trump’s declaration of the US “taking back” the Panama Canal, without further explanation, implies a resurgence of economic nationalism and territorial assertiveness. This could set a precedent for similar moves in other parts of the world, leading to geopolitical tensions.

Any disruption in significant maritime passages could have economic repercussions for India, which relies on global trade routes for its export economy. Furthermore, if the US adopts a unilateral approach to international treaties, India may need to reassess its foreign policy strategies to safeguard its interests.

Domestic Policies and Their Wider Ramifications

For the domestic audience in the US, Trump’s reiteration of free speech, directives on ending “catch and release” immigration policies, and his war on drug cartels signal a law-and-order-focused agenda. His commitment to dismantling drug networks aligns with India’s efforts to curb international narcotics trafficking. Strengthening Indo-US cooperation in tackling drug cartels is essential for regional security.

Additionally, Trump’s declaration that there are only two genders—male and female—highlights the cultural conservatism that may influence policymaking in other nations. The broader ramifications of different countries adopting similar policies warrant careful analysis, as they could affect global social and political dynamics.

Conclusion

Donald Trump’s return to the White House introduces challenges and opportunities for India and the global order. His strongman persona, economic protectionism, and aggressive stance on energy, immigration, and trade will shape the future trajectory of international relations.

For India, the key priorities will be safeguarding its trade interests, ensuring continued access to the US market, strengthening strategic ties while maintaining autonomy, and capitalizing on potential energy and space collaborations. New Delhi must also prepare for shifts in immigration policies that could impact its workforce and economic ties with the US.

Globally, Trump’s presidency will likely reinforce the US-China rivalry, influence energy and trade policies, and reshape alliances. As the world adapts to these changes, India’s ability to navigate this evolving landscape will be crucial in determining its economic growth, geopolitical standing, and strategic partnerships in the coming years.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest

More Articles Like This